Summer Synopsis: New York Islanders

Last season was a rough one for the Islanders in the first half of the season.  The team only won 19 of their first 45 games, leading to a coaching change with Patrick Roy taking over for Lane Lambert behind the bench.  It took a bit of time for them to find their stride but they got hot a little before the trade deadline, ultimately pulling themselves from being out of the playoff picture to finishing third in the Metropolitan Division although they bowed out in the first round to Carolina.  GM Lou Lamoriello didn’t have much flexibility this summer and largely elected to stay the course, hoping that New York’s finish to the season was a sign of things to come.

Draft

1-20: LW Cole Eiserman / U.S. National U18 Team (NTDP)
2-54: D Jesse Pulkkinen / JYP (Liiga)
2-61: C Kamil Bednarik / U.S. National U18 Team (NTDP)
4-115: G Dmitry Gamzin / Zvezda Moskva (VHL)
5-147: G Marcus Gidlof / Leksands IF J20 (J20 Nationell)
6-179: D Xavier Veilleux / Muskegon Lumberjacks (USHL)

Coming into the season, Eiserman was a popular pick to land in the top five.  While a little undersized, being a high-end scorer is an attribute that teams were expected to covet.  It didn’t happen that way.  Even though he broke the US National Team Development Program’s record for most goals scored (passing Cole Caufield, Phil Kessel, and Patrick Kane), Eiserman slipped out of the lottery altogether.  While Eiserman will likely spend a couple of years at Boston University, he projects as someone who should make an impact for the Isles sooner than a lot of others picked in that range.

Lamoriello didn’t waste any time signing Pulkkinen as the big blueliner inked his entry-level deal in mid-July.  He has some offensive upside and isn’t afraid of mixing it up, elements that will endear him to his coaches.  He will spend the upcoming season in Finland and is probably two or three years away from being NHL-ready.  Bednarik was Eiserman’s teammate with the NTDP and will continue to be his teammate at BU.  More of a two-way player than a raw gamebreaker like Eiserman, Bednarik is likely a few years away from turning pro.

With their other selections, the Islanders went with some longer-term options.  With a goaltending prospect cupboard that wasn’t the deepest, they opted for two netminders that carry at least four years of club control; Gamzin’s rights will be held indefinitely.  As for Veilleux, he’s committed to Harvard University but will spend another season in the USHL, meaning it could be five years before he signs.

Trade Acquisitions

The Isles were quiet on the trade front over the offseason.  Their only swap came more than a month before the draft when they flipped the 18th and 50th picks to Chicago for picks 20, 54, and 61.  Considering that they still wound up with Eiserman plus a pair of intriguing pieces in Pulkkinen and Bednarik, the move turned out pretty well for them as things stand.

UFA Signings

F Anthony Duclair (four years, $14MM)
F Liam Foudy (one year, $775K)*
F Mark Gatcomb (one year, $775K)*
G Marcus Hogberg (two years, $1.55MM)
F Fredrik Karlstrom (one year, $775K)*
D Mike Reilly (one year, $1.25MM)
F Maxim Tsyplakov (one year, $950K)*

*-denotes two-way contract

With limited cap space, Lamoriello used what he had primarily to try to upgrade the offense.  Duclair is a particularly interesting acquisition.  He struggled in San Jose but after Tampa Bay acquired him at the trade deadline, he came up just shy of being a point-per-game player down the stretch.  The 29-year-old has potted at least 23 goals in three of the last four years and this is a team that has scuffled offensively at times over the years.  Roy also has a comfort level with Duclair having coached him previously at the major junior level with QMJHL Quebec.  New York doesn’t need Duclair to produce as he did for the Lightning late in the season but if he can be a consistent 20-goal player and do some damage with his speed, this contract should work out for them.

Tsyplakov was the other addition of intrigue.  The 26-year-old had a breakout year in the KHL last season, notching 31 goals with Spartak Moscow; his previous career-high was 10.  That showing got him on a lot of NHL radars with New York being out a lot of teams for his services.  Capped at signing a one-year deal no matter who got him, Tsyplakov will be looking to land a full-time roster spot but will likely need to start in their bottom six, assuming they can create the cap room to keep him up – more on that later.

Reilly was picked up off waivers early in the season, a move that worked out quite well for both the team and the blueliner.  He wound up securing a full-time spot in the lineup, even holding onto one as players came back from injuries while he chipped in with 24 points in 59 games.  This is his fifth team since 2019 so it’s not surprising that Reilly decided to stay where he had some success; he should have a depth role on their back end this season.

RFA Re-Signings

D Dennis Cholowski (one year, $775K)*
F Simon Holmstrom (one year, $850K)
F Kyle MacLean (three years, $2.325MM)
F Tyce Thompson (one year, $775K)*
F Oliver Wahlstrom (one year, $1MM)

*-denotes two-way contract

Wahlstrom had a year to forget last season.  Coming off an ACL injury the year before, he was largely a non-factor on the nights he was in the lineup, recording just two goals and four assists in 32 games.  That had some wondering if the two sides could part ways.  Instead, they avoided arbitration with this deal, one that essentially represents a do-over on last season.  However, given the cheap deal and one-year term, it’s quite possible that the Isles still move on from Wahlstrom, either via a trade or even the waiver wire if they’re willing to risk losing him for no return.  Suffice it to say, things haven’t gone as planned so far for the 11th pick in the 2018 draft.

Holmstrom had a solid showing last season, scoring five shorthanded goals and 15 overall in 75 games despite playing nearly exclusively in the bottom six.  However, he elected to take less than his qualifying offer in order to secure a one-way contract which should help his chance of making the team in a similar role to last season’s.  MacLean was a feel-good story, making his NHL debut last season at the age of 25 and playing his way into a regular spot on the fourth line after that.  Rather than seek top dollar, he opted for security, getting three one-way years on his contract, an outcome that wouldn’t have seemed likely even at the midway point of last season.  Cholowski and Thompson, meanwhile, are primarily AHL veterans at this point of their careers.

Departures

D Sebastian Aho (Pittsburgh, two years, $1.55MM)
G Kenneth Appleby (Charlotte, AHL)
D Robert Bortuzzo (Utah, one year, $775K)*
F Cal Clutterbuck (unsigned)
F Brian Pinho (Bridgeport, AHL)
F Karson Kuhlman (Lukko, Liiga)
D Paul Ladue (MoDo, SHL)
F Otto Koivula (Vaxjo, SHL)
F Matt Martin (PTO with the Islanders)
D Robin Salo (Malmo, SHL)

*-denotes two-way contract

For the most part, New York lost predominantly AHL or depth players.  But their fourth line will look considerably different without Clutterbuck, who had been a fixture there for the past 11 seasons but wasn’t invited back despite recording 19 points and 273 hits.  Martin, meanwhile, wasn’t expected to be back but is hanging around on a PTO, one that’s expected to last into the start of the regular season so he may or may not be a departure when all is said and done depending on if he signs.

Bortuzzo was acquired early last season to offset some injuries on the back end, much like Reilly was.  But his role was much more limited, playing exclusively on the third pairing when he was in the lineup.  Aho, meanwhile, had worked his way from being a depth defender to a full timer on the roster, one who played in 129 games for New York over the past two seasons, predominantly on the third pairing as well.  But with their injured players returning and Reilly being retained, there wasn’t a vacant spot for Aho to potentially fill, resulting in him heading to the Penguins.

Salary Cap Outlook

At the moment, the Islanders have spent exactly to the $88MM Upper Limit (to the penny), per PuckPedia.  And that’s with Tsyplakov not being on the roster.  Presumably, they’re going to want to get him with the big club to start the season which has helped fuel the speculation around Wahlstrom’s future with the team.  MacLean is their only waiver-exempt player and since he makes the league minimum, sending him down isn’t enough.  Accordingly, expect to see some roster activity from the Isles in the coming weeks as they look to free up space for Tsyplakov, possibly Martin, while hoping to give themselves some wiggle room for in-season flexibility.  Lamoriello has some work to do to achieve that.

Key Questions

Can Sorokin Rebound? Through his first three seasons, Sorokin was an elite netminder, posting a 2.34 GAA along with a .924 SV% in 136 games.  That helped him earn an eight-year, $66MM contract extension last July, one that kicks in this season.  However, he struggled throughout last season, putting up a 3.01 GAA with a .908 SV%, a rate that was above the NHL average but well below his standards.  Those struggles resulted in Semyon Varlamov being the starter for their series against the Hurricanes.  Sorokin underwent back surgery this summer and while he isn’t expected to miss time, it only adds to the question of whether he can get back to the Vezina-contending form he has shown in the past.

Will The Offense Improve? New York finished in the bottom 12 offensively last season for the sixth straight year.  The only proven addition of note is Duclair, a player who is probably a middle-six forward.  He’ll help but he alone won’t bring this group to even a middle of the pack team.  They did fare a bit better in this regard following the coaching change but is that sustainable?  Of the 15 other playoff teams last season, the average number of goals scored was 276.  New York checked in at 246 with only Washington coming in below them.  If they want to get to that average, where are the extra 30 goals coming from?  And if they can get that and a bounce-back showing from Sorokin, the Islanders could make some noise this season.

Can Dobson Reach Another Level? Noah Dobson was certainly a bright spot on the blueline for New York last season.  Offensively, he blew past his career bests in assists (60) and points (70), finishing sixth and seventh league-wide in those categories for a defenseman.  Meanwhile, he logged over 24 minutes a night, becoming a legitimate number one blueliner.  Still just 24, how much more room is left to improve?  If he can get into that elite tier of defenders, he’ll give the Islanders an element they haven’t had for a while.  The timing would also be perfect as he’ll be a restricted free agent with arbitration eligibility next summer and will be looking to cash in.

Photos courtesy of USA Today Sports Images.