The Dallas Stars have taken a play out of the Calgary Flames book, having placed Gemel Smith on waivers prior to his arbitration hearing on Wednesday August 1st. Chris Johnston of Sportsnet reports that Smith actually cleared waivers today, though there had been no report yesterday of his assignment. The Flames used the same tactic earlier this month with Brett Kulak, in order to show the player’s relative value around the league. Smith is definitely an interesting player, but any acquiring team would have needed to quickly prepare for the arbitration hearing without the ability to reschedule it.
Smith, 24, played in 46 games for the Stars last season and scored 11 points, but was given very little opportunity to play consistent minutes. Averaging fewer than 10 minutes per game, the fourth-round pick was limited to being just an energy player for a team that struggled to find much secondary scoring. Dallas was extremely top heavy, playing their big three forwards—Jamie Benn, Tyler Seguin and Alexander Radulov—20 minutes or more each night while giving few chances to those lower in the lineup. That may change with new head coach Jim Montgomery, but it doesn’t necessarily mean a bigger opportunity for Smith.
After adding Blake Comeau and Valeri Nichushkin this summer, Smith will have to battle younger players like Jason Dickinson and Roope Hintz for a roster spot let alone regular minutes on the ice. The team is deeper on the wing this season and has to ride whichever hand is hottest in a must-win season. Dallas missed the playoffs again last season and can’t keep struggling in the middle of the Western Conference pack during the peak years of Benn, Seguin and John Klingberg. Smith should get a chance to impress at some point given his upcoming arbitration award and lack of waiver-exempt status, but he’s going to have to battle for it.
The fact that the rest of the league passed on Smith already should give Dallas renewed belief that they could sneak him through again in the season and send him to the minor leagues, but that’s not necessarily the case. Roster situations can change drastically over the next two months, and depending on the arbitration award (or settlement) teams could think he’s worth the risk.