Should The Panthers Put Dale Tallon Back in Charge?

Sun-Sentinel reporter Dave Hyde wonders if the Florida Panthers higher ups will come to their senses and allow Dale Tallon to finish the job he started. After a disastrous season that followed an extremely successful 2015-16 season, Tallon was given the new title of President of Hockey Operations while ceding the general manager’s chair to Tom Rowe. The results? A fired coach, a collapse to the end of the season, and more questions than answers. Fans are protesting the retention of Rowe in any capacity as he will not return to the bench next season. Hyde writes that putting Tallon back in charge of everything seems to be the best choice for the franchise’s future. Hyde adds that firing other key front office staff like Scott Luce and losing scouts who left the team has been attrition the Panthers couldn’t afford.

The move, when it was made, was seen as one that was a nod to analytics and more progressive viewpoints as the Panthers were barely a month removed from the best regular season in franchise history  Rowe’s moves did more than just tinker with a roster that was so successful–many of them were significant. The move to get Keith Yandle, who regressed from his 46 points (5-41) last season. Hyde also believes that the loss of Erik Gudbranson was felt and that the grand plan Rowe and others laid out never came close to fruition.

Of course, would Tallon actually want it? After all, the team apparently restructured the power only to say that nothing had changed back in December. Not to mention the unceremonious way he was asked to leave the general manager’s gig.

Then there’s the handling of Gerard Gallant, who was inexplicably fired following a Panthers loss to Carolina in Raleigh. The news, which came before photos of Gallant hailing a cab to leave the stadium, which reflected poorly on the organization. Though it was reported later that Gallant refused help from the team, the image was already seared into the minds of hockey folk aghast at the move and the purported treatment of the reining Jack Adams Trophy winner. Gallant denied later that he was let go due to a lack of embracing analytics.

Regardless, something must be done in Miami. Last year at this time, the Panthers were up and coming. Now they’re in a purgatory, unsure of what move to make. If Hyde were the man making the decisions, Dale Tallon would get his seat back in the general manager’s chair.

All that remains to be asked if he would still actually want it.